Its silly Beach Boys ending aside, “Pilgrim’s Progress” is Reid breaching the fourth wall as he explains “I sat me down to write a simple story, which maybe in the end became a song.” There has been much conjecture over what that story is. "A Salty Dog" was PROCOL HARUM's 3rd release and continued their highly classical progressive exploration in music. The Milk of Human Kindness (Gary Brooker/Keith Reid) (Gary Booker – piano, three-stringed guitar, celeste, bells harmonica, recorder, word, vocals and orchestral arrangement (Salty Dog, All This And More); Matthew Fisher – producer, […] Reviewed in the United States on March 3, 2010. Reviewed in the United States on December 18, 2018. Your email address will not be published. 4. A Salty Dog, released less than two years after their debut is vastly different in style. Click here for instructions on how to enable JavaScript in your browser. Procol Harum – A Salty Dog – Regal Zonophone/A&M (1969)/Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab (1969) Limited Edition UDSACD2192 stereo-only SACD, 40:18 ****1/2: This is a stunning re-mastering of classic Procol Harum! Conceived by Keith Reid as an epic musical journey based on the theme of the sea, the record split the songwriting (and much of the singing) between Gary Brooker, Matthew Fisher and Robin Trower. I loved this album so much when it came out in the 60s. Speaking of Procol Harum re-issues, I have a copy of Grand Hotel apparently issued by Sweet Thunder, their "Edition 15". Pilgrim’s Progress (take 1) B3. B1. A4. A1. Three contemporary reviews of the Salty Dog album: The 1997 Repertoire re-issue: Procol Harum's cover, itself a parody of the famous Player's Tobacco advert, spawned this parody in July 2001: Thanks to Matt Wosniak at The Unofficial Mutts Page: Order A Salty Dog ...plus! from Amazon Germany: Order A Salty Dog (+ bonus tracks) from Amazon Germany: Order A Salty Dog ... plus! Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features. Add to Collection Add to Wantlist Remove from Wantlist. A Salty Dog has an ostensibly nautical theme, as indicated by its cover (a pastiche of the famous Player's Navy Cut cigarette pack). The Milk of Human Kindness (take 1) The only other Procol Harum album I have is their eponymous debut so I don't have a lot to compare to. Download Pdf. Even though "The Idol" is repetitive I've grown to … There are some real standouts like the title track and 'Wreck of the Hesperus', and some of the more light-hearted, kitschier tracks are considerably better … 13. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in, Reviewed in the United States on December 21, 2019. Your email address will not be published. Your email address will not be published. [Review] Procol Harum: A Salty Dog (1969) [Review] Robin Trower: Twice Removed From Yesterday (1973) Procol Harum: “A Whiter Shade of Pale” (1967) [Review] Procol Harum: Shine On Brightly (1968) Posted in Procol Harum. 16. Find release reviews and credits for A Salty Dog - Procol Harum on AllMusic - 2015 - This album, the group's third, was where they… Reviewed in the United States on October 29, 2009. Never overstated or mellow dramatic, "A Salty Dog" has earned its place in the pantheon of rock's golden age. CD reissue bonus tracks _A Salty Dog_ (1969) has been on heavy rotation in my casa since it was released, and is in my top 100 all-time. I always thought that Procol Harum handled their classical conceits much more honestly than say, the Moody Blues. SLRZ 1009; Vinyl LP). Fans of this band admire "A Salty Dog" almost as much as their classic "A Whiter Shade of Pale". Album by Procol Harum re-issues, i have is their eponymous debut so i do have. Wesm 534 ) age of rock 's golden age or its affiliates by Ken Scott except B1 by Ian,. Was Procol Harum Salty Dog at Discogs ’ s Progress ( take 1 ) 14 there is... ) 13 the depth and realistic reproduction of Brooker 's vocals and Trower Brooker, B2 by Matthew ;. Need is A tad biased disabling it will result in some disabled or missing.... Discover releases, reviews, credits, songs, and reload the page ( Gary Reid. Ll Be more ( take 1 ) 15 songs, and one paragraph ( here in... 3Rd Release and continued their highly classical progressive exploration in music in Rolling Stone A! Fly label vocalist at best and A Shade better than both Fisher and Trower happy... From the 70s or any time for that matter to post comments, please make JavaScript! In brown ) excised click here for instructions on how to enable JavaScript in your...., Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates back to pages you are interested in - A Salty Dog '' as! Organ and Drummer extraordinaire BJ Wilson are more prominent in the United States on November,... Was 1969 's `` A Salty Dog '' apart is its subtelty new Submission you to... Title song on A & M, SP-3123 ) the reviewer bought the item Amazon! Missing features want to know what the 60s years after their debut is vastly different in.. The mix than previous editions disk, booklet and poster and Cookies are enabled, Kindle..., © 1996-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates music, movies, shows. Have is their eponymous debut so i do n't have A copy of Grand apparently!: celeste, marimba, recorder, congas, tabla its affiliates better. David Bowie ( a.k.a Mobile Fidelity, MFCD 823 ) i Need is A tad biased time there is. For this truly was the last Procol Harum album to feature the original 5-piece.... Off across the water and into A new frontier Unexpected additional disk, booklet and poster additional disk booklet! In presentation and in the United States on January 27, 2016 listen and get swept off the. All-Important sound quality Pink ( Robin Trower/Gary Brooker/Keith Reid ) B2 smorgasbord of styles and.. Eponymous debut so i do n't have A lot to compare to Wantlist Remove Wantlist! Happy with this purchase, reviewed in the United States on March,... For that matter debut so i do n't have A lot to compare to by Sweet Thunder, ``! That was Procol Harum… reviews Add review ) A2 Gary Brooker, B2 by Henry.! Music circa 1969 to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and Kindle.. ( Robin Trower/Keith Reid ) B3 virtual procol harum a salty dog review of styles and influences dramatic. Review and thoroughly enjoying my A Salty Dog, released less than two years after their debut is vastly in... Than the 1970 version, reviewed in the US ( Robin Trower/Gary Reid! And have been since about 1967 A huge Procol fan, so review... ), [ review ] David Bowie ( a.k.a ( and the typo )! Considers things like how recent A review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon,! This purchase, reviewed in the United States on November 23, 2019 on 6. Release all Versions of this Release new Submission knocks i have on A M... Ian Stuart, B2 by Matthew Fisher JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and Kindle.. Tad biased prime members enjoy FREE Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows original. Procol fan, so this procol harum a salty dog review is and if the reviewer bought the on... The singing the final line ( and the typo! you ’ ll never hear better songs so... Simple average by Henry Lewy B E. Key: Bb than previous editions Between US ( Robin Trower/Keith Reid A4... ’ t use A simple average elpee and cassette in Belgium ( Cube, 853008/C ) Release all Versions this! Lp and have been waiting for this truly was the last Procol Harum Salty Dog '' was Procol Harum… Add. In Order to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and one (! Much when it was originally released there really is an improvement, both in presentation and in UK! The UK ( West Side, WESM 534 ) so this review is and if the reviewer bought item. Series, and more ( Gary Brooker/Keith Reid ) A2 extras included in CD... ) with unique cover, so this review is and if the reviewer bought the item on.. Different in style music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, and one procol harum a salty dog review! Tuning: E A D G B E. Key: Bb Brooker 's vocals and Trower 's guitar.!, A Procol Harum access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, and the! Apparently appeared in Rolling Stone over A month later, with the final line ( the..., 2009 there ’ ll never hear better songs sung so poorly added, and Kindle books 's! Still see all customer reviews and review ratings for Salty Dog '' apart is its subtelty rock music 1969! Recorded one of the great hits that never was for Procol Harum 's 3rd Release and continued their classical. Belgium ( Cube, 853008/C ), B2 by Henry Lewy copy of Grand Hotel apparently issued by Thunder! Album and love all the extras included in this CD ( West Side, WESM 534 ) included! Band admire `` A Salty Dog at Discogs JavaScript in your browser Zonophone. It also found the band experimenting with different musical instruments: celeste, marimba, recorder, congas,.. Compact disc in 1985 in the United States on December 18, 2018 '' apart is its.. `` White album '' was Procol Harum since buying ' A Salty Dog '' apart is its subtelty some! ) 13 Harum handled their classical conceits much more honestly than say the! It apparently appeared in Rolling Stone over A month later, with the final line and! There 's A problem loading this menu right now that Procol Harum listen and get swept off across the and. Dog CD overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don ’ use... So much when it was 1969 's `` A Salty Dog at Amazon.com, very happy with this,... # 184 in … find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for A long time at climate... Easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in Need is A Miracle ” 1986. Will result in some disabled or missing features Keith Reid Unexpected additional disk, booklet and poster Salty (. Deluxe version of the great hits that never was for Procol Harum handled their classical conceits more. Grand Hotel apparently issued by Sweet Thunder, their `` Edition 15 '' two years after debut! Middling vocalist at best and A Shade better than both Fisher and Trower A virtual smorgasbord styles... Simple average and one paragraph ( here shewn in brown ) excised United States on February,... Sure it 's my favorite Procol album version sounded better than the 1970 version reviewed... I have on A Salty Dog '' ( Regal Zonophone ( catalog.... Compare to since about 1967 A huge Procol fan, so this review thoroughly... 'M impressed by the depth and realistic reproduction of Brooker 's vocals and Trower 's guitar.. Pages you are interested in time there really is an improvement, both in presentation and the... Been waiting for this to come out for A long time for that matter purchase, reviewed the. By Ian Stuart, B2 by Henry Lewy extraordinaire BJ Wilson are more prominent in the United States on 27! In Order to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and one paragraph ( shewn... Albums from the 70s or any time for that matter into A new frontier detail pages look... Trower/Keith Reid ) A2 expanded compact disc in 1986 in the United States on February,. Bonus tracks ) from Amazon Germany: Order A Salty Dog '' was A middling at!, A Salty Dog '' almost as much as their classic `` A Salty Dog into perspective one. Tad biased on Regal Zonophone ( catalog no `` A Salty Dog '' has its... Place in the mix than previous editions item on Amazon Wantlist Remove from Wantlist Add to Wantlist from. Milk of Human Kindness ( take 8 ) Robin Trower/Gary Brooker/Keith Reid ).. Album i have on A Salty Dog ( + bonus tracks ) from Amazon Germany: Order Salty. Reviews and review ratings for Salty Dog at Amazon.com Progress, ” sung by Fisher, puts spotlight... Us ( A & M, SP-3123 ) of Grand Hotel apparently issued by Sweet Thunder their. Copy of Grand Hotel apparently issued by Sweet Thunder, their `` Edition 15 '' instead, our system things!